Luck has run out for prep-school ballerina, Fallon Hayes. First, she fumbles her Nutcracker audition, then her best friend suddenly moves across the country. Fallon assumes her senior year is ruined…but she never dreams it will turn deadly.

The quaint ski village of Everspring, Colorado may be a picturesque tourist destination, but there are secrets simmering below the charming facade. Fallon's fellow yearbook club member, Alex Redmond, is a true crime addict convinced foul play is afoot in the condo complex across from their school. With floor-to-ceiling windows, the building is a proverbial fish bowl—and the lives of its residents are the yearbook club’s guilty pleasure “reality show.”

Fallon laughs off Alex’s theories until the woman in 2B goes missing. The ragtag group of yearbook club members are quick to investigate her disappearance. But instead of finding the woman, they find one of their own brutally murdered.

When the police overlook key clues, the amateur sleuths must kick their investigation into high gear. After hitting some dead ends, they start a true crime YouTube channel to bring in new leads. As the tips roll in, Fallon narrows in on the killer, as well as the shocking reason why her best friend left town for good.